I think I have at least two with me somewhere at home. I am not even sure of how many copies of The Silmarillion I own any more. Those are rare and may be worth some money.Īs for any minor textual errors that may have been corrected in some edition or printing, I am not enough of a collector to care. If I were in a collecting mood I would probably want to find copies of the dummy Silmarillion books from 1977. He tries to cover 60 years of history in 2 short paragraphs so I should probably cut him some slack. Peter Collier describes various editions of The Silmarillion here (although he implies it was begun in 1917 - The Book of Lost Tales is another book altogether). If you’re going to buy any edition of The Silmarillion I would get an edition illustrated by Ted Nasmith. What was the point behind it if it wasn’t going to try to fix the flaws of the first edition? Well, I live in my own corner of the universe. When I bought the second edition of The Silmarillion I think I literally threw it across the room because it didn’t change anything significant that I could tell. The printing flaw on page 229 did not introduce errors into the story it simply reflected a misaligned printing plate that fell out of position during the first print run (or something like that).

This Website explains what to look for if you want to buy a 1st edition of The Silmarillion (I have owned two but no longer care if I have one that may become valuable in 100 years). To be honest, I don’t know if anyone has cataloged errors of (in-story) fact in printings of The Silmarillion, or even if there are any such errors. Q: Is There a Definitive Edition or Printing of The Silmarillion?ĪNSWER: The reader who submitted this question has spent time and money collecting the best possible editions he can find of The Lord of the Rings but is not certain if any effort should be made to collect a specific edition or printing of The Silmarillion.

The silmarillion book buy